The Draft Digital Fairness Act, Part 2: Addictive Features, Gaming and Enforcement

This is the second of two articles on the draft Digital Fairness Act published by the European Commission. Part 1 covered the background and the dark patterns provisions whilst Part 2 covers a selection of provisions from Articles 14 to 28, along with the draft’s enforcement and remedies.
Gaming and minors: Articles 14 to 16
Three articles concern gaming mechanics:
- Article 14 would require virtual currencies to show the corresponding monetary value of the virtual items or products they buy.
- Article 15 would require information about variable reward systems to be given to the consumer, and says they could not be offered to children.
- Article 16 would prohibit pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanisms for minors.
For Articles 14 and 15, the proposed EU KIDS Act would cover these practices when they relate to video-sharing platform services, social networking services and AI companion chatbots. Which rules apply to children on those services would depend on the EU KIDS Act, which is not yet in force.
Addictive features: Article 17
Under Article 17, a trader with an addictive feature would have to provide tools to disable it. The draft gives four examples:
- autoplay
- unrelated consumer notifications
- features that incentivise engagement at regular times, such as streaks and login calendars
- engagement prompts that encourage continued use
Pricing, trials, withdrawal and customer service
Articles 18 and 19 concern ticket price and virtual queue transparency. The whole price, the number of tickets and any changes, including the maximum price, would have to be displayed at all stages before the purchase is finalised.
Article 20 concerns free trials. The trader would have to obtain the consumer’s express agreement to renewing a free trial. Yet, certain subscription types will have a 1 month withdrawal period, instead of 14 days. This includes video and audio subscriptions.
Article 24 would introduce a withdrawal function for distance contracts concluded through an online interface. This was taken from the Consumer Rights Directive. The wording would have to be easy and comprehensible, and the function available during the withdrawal period.
Article 25 would ensure that communication with a human being in customer service is possible after a contract is concluded. This is with aim to ensure that a consumer can reach a human being instead of an automated bot regarding after sale customer services.
Article 28 would prohibit unsolicited commercial communications that are entirely automated and sent for direct marketing. This rule is currently in Article 13 of the ePrivacy Directive and could make its way into the DFA if passed.
Enforcement
Enforcement would be left to member states. The Commission could investigate and enforce in cases of widespread infringements with a Union dimension.
Articles 14 to 16 would be enforced by the competent authorities designated under the EU KIDS Act. Lastly, for Article 17, when the trader is an online platform provider under the Digital Services Act, the digital services coordinator would be the enforcement body.
Remedies
Member states could provide compensation, and they would decide the amount. The Commission could impose a fine not exceeding 6% of worldwide turnover.
Link to source: https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/consumer-protection-law/digital-fairness-act_en





