The Draft Digital Fairness Act, Part 1: Background and Dark Patterns

The European Commission has published a draft Digital Fairness Act. This is the first of two articles on what it contains. Part 1 covers the background, how the draft relates to existing law, and its provisions on dark patterns, influencer marketing and minors.
Background
In its 2020 consumer policy strategy, the New Consumer Agenda, the Commission announced that it would analyse whether additional legislation or other action was needed to ensure equal fairness online and offline. Therefore, in 2022, it launched a Fitness Check of EU consumer law on digital fairness, to evaluate whether the current rules are fit for purpose in the digital environment. The Fitness Check covers three directives: the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, the Consumer Rights Directive and the Unfair Contract Terms Directive.
On 3 October 2024, the Commission published a Staff Working Document with the conclusions. It identified several harmful and evolving practices that consumers face online and pointed to areas for improvement. These included tackling the most harmful practices such as dark patterns, preventing regulatory fragmentation, promoting fair growth, ensuring the coherent application of EU consumer law and the EU digital rulebook, facilitating more effective enforcement, and simplifying existing rules without compromising the level of protection.
How the draft relates to existing law
In the DFA, Articles 6 to 9 use wording similar to the UCPD. They prohibit misleading practices and misleading omissions, aggressive commercial practices, and coercion and undue influence. However, the UCPD itself is not changed.
The DFA would be a regulation rather than a directive, so it would apply directly in member states without needing to be transposed.
Article 10: dark patterns
Article 10 is an explicit provision on dark patterns. Traders would not be allowed to design, organise or operate their online interfaces, including visual, auditory and other components, in a manner “likely to deceive or manipulate consumers,” or in a manner likely to otherwise materially distort their economic behaviour.
The draft lists specific practices:
- false claims about the availability or popularity of a product
- false scarcity messages about popularity and availability during the ordering process
- defaults that require consumers to reject additional products
- presenting the option to decline an invitation to purchase, or to continue the supply of a product, as the wrong choice
- creating the false impression that the consumer has no option other than the prominently featured one
- persistently asking consumers to make a choice, or change a choice, they have already made
- trick wording, including double negatives
- making an invitation to purchase more prominent than the alternative
- false social proof, or false claims that a matter requires the consumer’s attention, such as false message notifications from another consumer or a trader
- making cancellation more difficult than is reasonably necessary
Influencers and minors
Article 11 regulates influencer marketing so that the commercial intent of communications is clear and explicit. Traders carrying out this activity would not be allowed to include direct exhortations to minors to buy products, or to create the impression that a product is appropriate for minors when it is not.
Articles 12 and 13 would prohibit personalised advertising and pricing aimed at minors. The trader would not be obliged to process additional personal data to assess whether the consumer is a minor.
What comes next
Part 2 covers Articles 14 to 28 and the draft’s enforcement and remedies. The articles include virtual currencies, variable reward systems, addictive features, ticket pricing transparency and the withdrawal function.
Link to source: https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/consumer-protection-law/digital-fairness-act_en





