Legal Updates
5 min read

From Average to Vulnerable Consumer: What a European Parliament Briefing Recommends for Digital Markets

Published on
November 18, 2026

A briefing written by Prof. Dr. Emilia Mišćenić of the University of Rijeka, requested by the Internal Market and Consumer Protection Committee of the European Parliament, examines how EU consumer law treats people in digital environments. It recommends changes to the average consumer benchmark and to the concept of the vulnerable consumer, for the Digital Fairness Act.

The digital asymmetry

It starts from an imbalance of power. Algorithms, profiling, behavioural targeting, personalisation, dark patterns and pre-selected defaults create a growing gap between businesses and consumers, and can steer choices “without consumers’ full awareness or understanding.” The briefing cites a Commission estimate of consumer detriment of no less than EUR 7.9 billion per year, without counting harm to health, mental well-being and society.

This asymmetry is structural, the briefing stresses. It comes from the architecture of digital marketplaces and “potentially applies to all consumers.” Drawing on a 2024 BEUC study, it describes three elements: a relational element (unequal power), an architectural element (environments designed to exploit vulnerabilities) and a privacy element (data collection and profiling that enable targeting). Digital tools also make it easier to circumvent rules on withdrawal, information and personal data, and around 40% of online traders still fail to inform consumers of their withdrawal right.

The average consumer benchmark

The current benchmark treats the average consumer as reasonably well informed and reasonably observant and circumspect. It comes from the Gut Springenheide case (C-210/96) and was codified in recital 18 of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.

According to the briefing, the benchmark is criticised as a homo economicus model, and information-based protection is insufficient where information is manipulated, hidden or presented without sufficient transparency. The Commission’s Fitness Check points to a growing mismatch between the benchmark and real behaviour. In the Digital Fairness Act consultation, changing the average consumer definition was the most frequently chosen measure, at 65% of respondents who favoured further action.

How the Court of Justice has applied it

The Court has shown some flexibility, the briefing notes. Depending on the circumstances, it applies the objective average consumer standard while recognising consumers’ weaker bargaining position, limited knowledge, cognitive biases and vulnerability. Cases listed include:

  • Océano (joined cases C-240/98 to C-244/98), on the consumer’s weak position in bargaining power and knowledge
  • mBank (C-139/22), which confirms the objective standard
  • Compass Banca (C-646/22), where the Court applies the objective standard but does not exclude taking into account the influence of cognitive biases where they are likely to materially distort behaviour
  • Duarte Hueros (C-32/12), on the unaware consumer, who does not appreciate the extent of their rights
  • Amazon EU (C-649/17), on the particularly vulnerable consumer

The vulnerable consumer

Today’s concept of a vulnerable consumer focuses mainly on personal characteristics such as age, disability, physical or mental infirmity and credulity, rather than on external factors that affect consumer choices. The briefing describes it as too narrow and applied unevenly across EU legislation, with sector-specific approaches in payment accounts, accessibility, the DSA and the proposed EU Kids Act, and divergent national case law. Some Member States have added their own criteria, such as Spain’s Article 3.2 of its General Consumer Protection Law, which refers to personal, economic, educational or social circumstances.

What it recommends

For the Digital Fairness Act, the recommendations are:

  • updating the average consumer benchmark to reflect external digital factors such as platform design, automation, data-driven personalisation, algorithmic decision-making, complexity and the risks of online transactions
  • broadening the definition of a vulnerable consumer to give more weight to external factors, and establishing additional criteria for identifying vulnerable consumers
  • introducing the concepts of digital vulnerability and digital asymmetry
  • improving consistent interpretation and enforcement of EU consumer law through these revised benchmarks and concepts
  • simplifying and coordinating existing consumer protection rules, including with the Digital Services Act, the GDPR, the future EU Kids Act and current EU consumer directives

The caveats

The briefing includes several limits. The UCPD already covers online practices, so the update would clarify rather than create protection. Digital asymmetry or vulnerability would not, on its own, establish that a practice is unfair, and the test would still be whether the practice causes or is likely to cause a transactional decision the consumer would not otherwise have taken. Effectiveness would depend on the wording of the amendments and on how courts and authorities apply them.

Fairpatterns’ view

Fairpatterns has said for a long time that people have very limited rationality, and we welcome the recognition that the average consumer model does not reflect real behaviour. In our view, recognising that people are vulnerable online should also shape the legal obligations that follow.

In our reading of the draft Digital Fairness Act, addictive features can stay as long as users can opt out. That sits uneasily with the idea that people act on cognitive biases, because such switches are rarely visible and people rarely check their settings. We think a quick crash test, carried out before release, should check that a digital or AI product contains no predatory design.

Full briefing: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2026/789730/ECTI_BRI(2026)789730_EN.pdf

Amurabi helped us think out of the box in a very powerful way

Jolling de Pree

Partner at De Brauw

"Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat."

Name Surname

Position, Company name